Article Distribution vs. Guest Blogging: Is There a Difference?
By Karon Thackston © 2009, All Rights Reserved
To many people, the idea of guest blogging is fresh and new and very “Web 2.0.” Personally, I find the discussion to be a rather déjà vu-like experience. In fact, one participant on my blog responded to a post about articles by asking how I would contrast guest blogging with article marketing. He wanted to know how I chose between placing my articles on directories and writing an exclusive blog post. The short answer is: I don’t.
Remembering the Good Old Days of Article Marketing
Circa 1990, the first article directories began to pop up online with the invention of ezines (email magazines). Many publishers of these soon-to-be-popular email newsletters quickly got tired of writing all the content themselves. Others decided to offer compilations of recent articles published by others about a particular topic.
The article directories provided a wonderful new outlet for gathering quality content in exchange for a simple bio at the end with a link back to the author’s site. Articles were written to provide quality information to readers in the hope that they would favor the author with a click.
A few of the many benefits of article marketing were (and still are):
> > Increasing traffic to your website
> > Positioning before a highly targeted audience
> > Branding yourself as an expert
> > SEO
> > Online networking and exposure before new groups of people
> > Free advertising
> > Infinite archiving of your material
> > Almost instant propagation throughout the Internet
With changes in link popularity, it soon became common knowledge that using keyword-rich anchor text carried more weight with engines than simple http: links. As is typical with so many Internet-based marketing methods, the article marketing landscape began to be overtaken by spammers.
A Twisted Sense of Article Marketing
A push for quantity quickly took over the article marketing arena and left quality articles in their wake. The invention of article writing software that illegally harvests snippets of text from existing online content and the invention of article blaster software gave speed to those looking to distribute what are now referred to as “junk articles.”
While this may have caused a decrease in the quality of links coming from article directories, the other marketing benefits remain to this day. Quality articles that get picked up from directories and republished on website pages, in ezines and on blogs still enjoy the benefits article marketing has always offered.
Enter Guest Blogging
The advent of blogging and other social media outlets gave new opportunities for professionals to share their expertise with others. Companies as well as individuals found many advantages to publishing blogs including:
> > Increasing traffic to your website
> > Positioning before a highly targeted audience
> > Branding yourself as an expert
> > SEO
Blog Post Shortcuts Inspire & Empower You To Write Unique Blog Posts… Fast
My Best-Kept Blogging Secret Can Cut Your Writing Time In Half. Each Blog Post Shortcut Includes:
- A Customizable Type Of Blog Post And How To Make It Work For You
- Quick Research Resources
- Blog Post Title Suggestions
- Opening Paragraph Tips
- How To Write The Body Of The Post
- Call-To-Action Ideas
- Monetization Ideas
- Search Optimization Recommendations
I understand that I will also receive weekly articles & videos plus periodic discounts, product notices & more. I can unsubscribe at any time.
> > Online networking and exposure before new groups of people
> > Free advertising
> > Infinite archiving of your material
> > Almost instant propagation throughout the Internet
(Hmm… sounds familiar. Where have I heard this before?)
When we look back at blogging after two or three more years, will it have followed a path similar to article distribution? Will the evil, greedy powers that be attempt to stamp out the benefits of guest blogging in the near future? It’s very possible. We’re seeing it to some extent already. Trackbacks and ping backs are being manipulated by spammers as we speak.
Search Engine Optimization Issues
The same dark SEO clouds that hang over article marketing can be seen drifting towards blogs. Concerns about duplicate content can be voiced with regard to blog replication as well as articles. Entire blogs are duplicated on scraper sites every single day within seconds of the original posts being made public.
Should you be concerned? I’m not.
Truth is, article marketing is not devoid of search engine benefits as some claim. While the link quality of article directories themselves may have been degraded over time, they only account for one source of links. That’s because the article directories were just a jumping off point. They should never have been viewed as the final destination of articles. The goal has always been to have your article picked up from directories and reprinted on authority sites or blogs. That’s where your linking benefits come in.
Even if I get no SEO benefits from article marketing or guest blogging, I’d still do both on a regular basis. It’s not an either/or choice for me: it’s good marketing. Since long before the Internet was ever thought of, professionals would strive to gain exposure by having their articles published in print magazines. This type of marketing has proven to be successful for decades, online and off, and it’s still a valid marketing method today.
Want to make the most of your article marketing campaign? Learn effective tactics and techniques to boost link popularity and rankings with articles. Get more info today at http://www.searchenginecollege.com/article-marketing-distribution-course.shtml.
Hi Karon! Great article. I wish more people would view article marketing the way you do. I have always advocated that article marketing should consider human beings first — ask, “What do people want to read? What do magazines/newsletters want to publish?” And then write your articles to that end. Then, if you want to add a keyword phrase that people actually search for to the first 3 words of your title and your summary, you’re well on your way to satisfying both humans and search engines.
Hi Marnie! Good to see you. I agree. Whether you get SEO credit or not, you’re bound to get new clients if you write great articles.
I agree with many of the things that Karon says.
I remember spending hours generating great content (most of it on my travel experiences) and submitting it to various ezines etc.
That was when I thought Google was ‘God’ and was deathly afraid of evoking its anger.
LOLOL. You know, Alex. I think most people have that same perception – at least in the beginning. Thanks for stopping by.
I think one valuable aspect people need to realize is that article marketing is just one avenue of many. You are going to get slightly different results with every effort you take.
Welcome Nick! You’re right. Another thing most people seem to misunderstand is that article marketing includes article distribution AND guest blogging. It also includes offline article submissions. For some reason, many see these as completely separate events.
I enjoyed the article. The viewpoints are interesting! I would like to agree with all said here, but there’s one point of difference that I see between articles and blog posts:
An article is written to provide certain piece of information. A blog post is written for that purpose too, but if a blog post doesn’t try to get its audience involved into a line of communication and interaction, its mission isn’t accomplished.
Welcome Rahman. That’s true. But a good article will do the same thing… get people talking. That’s my point. Blog posts and guest blogging is part of the article marketing process. They are not two different things.
Hi Karon,
I disagree with Rahman when it is said that articles and posts are different.
Article Marketing is an integrand part of my SEO (I do submit my articles daily to about 150 different directories). The article that I submit each day is my blog post.
I make sure to write each and everyday a high quality article for my blog (where therefore it becomes a blog post); so I have to disagree that they are different.
Sadly, it is a fact that the article directories are more and more filled with junk articles, and so are the search engines with junk/spam websites; yet it doesn’t stop people from using them, right?
Simply because in the end quality will prevail. On the search engines, if you have a good website, people can see the difference with a spam one, same goes for the articles. I do believe that if you write and submit quality articles, sooner or later people will pick them up and publish them despite the fact that there’s a lot of junk articles too around them.
Sorry about the dragging comment, but it had to be said.
Thanks for stopping by Nicolas.
I have read many posts in forums about how article marketing is dead, but I disagree. I’ve been using it over the last year or so and it definitely helps. If the benefit it confers is eroded, then it must have been extremely powerful in the past!
I suspect it will always be of some value. Even if there’s no SEO benefit, you are still putting your ideas, name and site in front of a wide audience. That has to be worth something.
I agree, Matt.